• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Signup for Emails
  • What You Can Do
  • About True Dignity
    • About the Board
    • Contact Us
  • Links
  • Report Abuse

True Dignity

Citizens Against Assisted Suicide

Ad example

Suicide is never death with dignity, and assisted suicide legislation threatens true patient choices at the end of life.

Doing Away with a False Assumption: No One Has to Choose Between Uncontrolled Pain and a Shortened Life

June 23, 2011 by Administrators

Articles on assisted suicide, and especially in the comments to online articles, often assert that giving people enough medication to provide effective pain relief in terminal illness is the same, or almost the same, as prescribing medication for the purpose of committing suicide, because doses of painkillers high enough to control the pain of dying hasten death. The assumption is false. Good pain relief may extend life. It does not shorten it.

 
As early as 2003, The Lancet medical journal published a review of the scientific evidence for the assumption that pain medication in adequate doses hastens death. It found that increased use of pain killers like morphine at the end of life does not hasten death (http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanonc/article/PIIS1470-2045%2803%2901079-9/fulltext.).

 
Other studies have shown that good pain relief for patients believed to be terminally ill may actually extend life.

 
In September 2010 The New York Times reported on a study which found that patients receiving palliative, or concurrent, care –combining treatment aimed at curing disease with medication adequate to control pain and other symptoms– lived longer than a control group of patients receiving only curative treatment  (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/19/health/19care.html).

 
A study published in The Journal of Pain and Symptom Management in 2007 found extended life in patients receiving hospice care, which is aimed only at relieving suffering. These patients had given up curative care and were only receiving support services and all the medication needed to control pain, yet they still lived longer than patients receiving only curative care  (http://www.hpccr.org/pilotFiles/resourceLibraryFiles/files/Comparing%20hospice%20and%20nonhospice%20survival-JPSM-Connor-2007.pdf.).

 
Dr. Pippa Hawley (http://palliativecare.med.ubc.ca/about-us/people/), a palliative care specialist at the University of British Columbia Medical Center, wrote the following in a December 30, 2010 letter to Vancouver’s online newspaper Straight.com.
As a medical professional experienced in the care of cancer patients, I can advise that though a very large single dose of a highly potent opioid such as heroin may suppress respiration sufficiently to cause death in a person who is not used to it or who does not have pain, when opioids are used appropriately for patients with pain due to advanced illness such as cancer, survival is actually longer.

These medications are commenced in low doses,usually in long-acting or slow-release formulations, and the dose can be
gradually and safely increased as much as necessary to keep pain controlled, without any respiratory depression(http://www.straight.com/article-366028/vancouver/pain-medication-can-extend-cancer-patients-lives).

Using doses of medication adequate to control pain has long been considered ethical under the principal of double effect, which considered  hastened death an unintended side effect.  Now physicians no longer have to fall back on this principle, because its underlying assumption about hastened death is false.  Once again: adequate pain relief does not shorten life and may extend it.  Giving a patient doses of painkillers high enough to make him comfortable does not  even approach the ethical line separating it from assisted suicide.  Assisted suicide eliminates suffering by eliminating the sufferer, sometimes long before he is suffering, and without certain knowledge of whether he ever would suffer, simply because he fears his possible suffering or has been taught by our culture that his care would be a burden to his family or the state.

There is no way assisted suicide can ever be made either ethical or safe.  That is why it is illegal in all except two US states and four European countries and why it should be illegal everywhere.

 

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Stay Active!

  • Get Action Alerts Emails
  • Make Calls
  • Write Letters

Vermont Government

  • Governor Phil Scott
  • Lt. Governor David Zuckerman
  • State Reps By District
  • State Senators By District
  • VT Legislative Directory

Stay Informed!

  • Join our email list

More to See

(no title)

January 16, 2011 By Administrators

PHYSICAL MOVEMENTS OR OTHER EXTERNAL SIGNS OF DISTRESS ARE SOMETIMES EXHIBITED”

February 28, 2022 By Administrators

ACTION ALERT

January 11, 2022 By carolyn

Tags

abuse Act 39 Another Defeat for Assisted Suicide coercion Letters to the Editor: Pauline Austin Opponents of Assisted Suicide Greatly Outnumber Proponents at Manchester Forum. S.74 safeguards Story of a person with disabilities opposing assisted suicide telehealth

Article Categories

  • Ablism (2)
  • Acceptance of Unintended Consequences (5)
  • Action Alert (3)
  • Administrative (4)
  • Agism (4)
  • Alerts (24)
  • Animal euthanasia argument (4)
  • Board (1)
  • Brittany Maynard (1)
  • California (4)
  • Canada (3)
  • Canada Supreme Court (1)
  • Cheapness of Assisted Suicide (5)
  • Choice Becomes "Duty" to Die (14)
  • Chronic Diseases Rendered Terminal by Non-treatment (3)
  • Classism and Assisted Suicide (4)
  • Colorado (2)
  • Commentary (27)
  • Compassion and Choices (7)
  • Conflict of Interest (4)
  • Connecticut (6)
  • Conscience Rights (2)
  • Cost Cutting Agenda of Barbara Coombs Lee (2)
  • Countering the PAS lobby (1)
  • Court rulings (1)
  • CT (1)
  • Damage to Family (3)
  • Damage to Helpers (1)
  • Death with Dignity (3)
  • Defeats in other states (10)
  • Depression (8)
  • Devaluation of Lives with Disabilities (32)
  • Disability Rights Groups' Opposition (30)
  • Doctor's Power (3)
  • Dying with Real Dignity (1)
  • Editorials (5)
  • Elder Abuse (25)
  • Election 2014 (3)
  • Error Possibility (2)
  • Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide Contagion (2)
  • Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide Two Sides of the Same Coin (8)
  • Exemption options (4)
  • Expansion of Assisted Suicide/Euthanasia (16)
  • Georgia (3)
  • Germany (1)
  • Healthy people helped to commit suicide (2)
  • Language manipulation (3)
  • Legal Opinions (7)
  • Legislative Efforts in Other Countries (3)
  • Legislative Efforts in Other States (10)
  • Legislative Testimony (1)
  • Letters to the Editors of Newspapers (13)
  • Letters to the Legislature (2)
  • Maine (1)
  • Maryland (1)
  • Massachusetts (3)
  • Medical Opinions (18)
  • Medical Power (5)
  • Medical Societies (6)
  • Montana (2)
  • Moratorium (2)
  • Murder Invitation (3)
  • Nevada (1)
  • Never Investigated (1)
  • New Jersey (5)
  • New Mexico (1)
  • New York (4)
  • New York (1)
  • Not a Peaceful Death (5)
  • Oregon (4)
  • Other Countries (3)
  • Other States (11)
  • Out of State/General (10)
  • Palliative Care (7)
  • Personal Stories (6)
  • Pharmacists (6)
  • Polls (4)
  • Pro Assisted Suicide (1)
  • Prognosis Inaccuracy (3)
  • Racism and Assisted Suicide (1)
  • Randy Brock (1)
  • Rationing (3)
  • Reasons to Oppose (3)
  • Rejections of Assisted Suicide in Other Countries (3)
  • Rejections of Assisted Suicide in other states (5)
  • Relatives Won't Know (4)
  • Religious "movement" (1)
  • Repeal Effort (4)
  • Richard Doerflinger (1)
  • Selfishness of Proponents (3)
  • Selling of Suicide (7)
  • Silencing Opposition (2)
  • Slippery Slope (23)
  • Suicide Contagion (23)
  • Suicide Increase (10)
  • Suicide Tourism (3)
  • Talking Points (2)
  • Testimony before non-VT legislative bodies (3)
  • Transparency Lack (1)
  • True Dignity (22)
  • Uncategorized (375)
  • Unused Drug Dangers (1)
  • Unworkability if Regulations Attempt to Make AS "Safe" (1)
  • Updates (1)
  • US (1)
  • Vermont (18)
  • Vermont Alliance for Ethical Health Care (5)
  • Vermont Governor (4)
  • Vermont Legislature (61)
  • Videos (24)
  • Vote Count on Passage (4)
  • Vote Results (5)

Footer

Tags

abuse Act 39 Another Defeat for Assisted Suicide coercion Letters to the Editor: Pauline Austin Opponents of Assisted Suicide Greatly Outnumber Proponents at Manchester Forum. S.74 safeguards Story of a person with disabilities opposing assisted suicide telehealth

Recent

  • (no title)
  • PHYSICAL MOVEMENTS OR OTHER EXTERNAL SIGNS OF DISTRESS ARE SOMETIMES EXHIBITED”
  • ACTION ALERT
  • S.74: A step down the slippery slope
  • Vermont’s Second Assisted Suicide Report Does Not Reassure

Search

Copyright © 2025 · True Dignity · Log in