• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Signup for Emails
  • What You Can Do
  • About True Dignity
    • About the Board
    • Contact Us
  • Links
  • Report Abuse

True Dignity

Citizens Against Assisted Suicide

Ad example

Suicide is never death with dignity, and assisted suicide legislation threatens true patient choices at the end of life.

Whose Choice is It? Oregon Rations End of Life Care

August 10, 2013 by Administrators

In 2008, when Oregonian cancer patients Barbara Wagner and Randy Stroup received letters from the state Medicaid program denying payment for prescribed and wanted chemotherapy  and listing assisted suicide among the alternatives that would be covered,  they were devastated  at being condemned to premature deaths and angry at the infringement on their personal autonomy (http://abcnews.go.com/Health/story?id=5517492&page=1).  Informed by the press of the huge cost savings of assisted suicide vs treatment, a significant portion of the public agreed with  Wagner and Stroup, enough that, according to testimony given before the VT Senate Judiciary Committee in the spring of 2012,  Oregon stopped offering to cover assisted suicide in its denial-of-treatment letters.

What was not stopped, however, was the rationing of health care that makes Oregon’s Medicaid program unique among the 50 states.  Oregon is the only state with an overt, specific rationing program.   The Oregon Health Evidence Review Commission (HERC) is a body charged with ranking health care services and deciding which will be covered and which will not, based on its perception of their benefits to the affected population.

In short, poor citizens of Oregon do not get to choose the type of end of life care they want.  Experts choose for them.  Of course insurance companies have always denied coverage. What is unique in Oregon is that assisted suicide is available as an alternative to treatment.  It is cheap.   It is always cheaper for a human being to cease to exist than to do anything else.  Once  legalized, assisted suicide is simply there, a pressuring presence in thought or conversation, especially at the end of life but not exclusively so, as is indicated by Oregon’s rising general suicide rate since legalization .

Below, in italics, is a post from the Medical Futility Blog (http://medicalfutility.blogspot.com/2013/08/oregon-starts-rationing-end-of-life.html) about HERC’s decision, at its August 2013 meeting, to change the criteria for restriction or denial of end of life chemotherapy from an expected two years’ life expectancy to the experts’ perception that a patient is too weak for chemotherapy or that he is not benefiting from it.

There is certainly a time to stop treatment aimed at achieving a cure for disease, when that treatment is futile.  The problem in Oregon is that HERC makes the decision, a decision which in the end should be made by the patient after a frank conversation with a doctor who knows him well, a decision which should never be made under the cloud of legal assisted suicide.

Friday, August 9, 2013

Oregon Starts Rationing End-of-Life Treatment

Yesterday, at the monthly meeting of the Oregon Health Education (Sic) Review Commission, the HERC adopted restrictions on the type of treatment that cancer patients under Medicaid can receive.  The new guidelines go into effect in October 2013.

An earlier revision said patients expected to live two years or less were to have restricted treatment.  But that was revised to instead impose restrictions on terminally ill patients too weak to withstand chemotherapy or who have had multiple rounds of treatment and are not improving.  So, if the patient’s organ systems are so fragile they are getting so close to the end of life, then they will not be eligible for treatment aimed at curing their cancer.  But treatment for pain and nausea, including some surgeries and radiation, will still be covered.

 

 

Filed Under: Rationing

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Stay Active!

  • Get Action Alerts Emails
  • Make Calls
  • Write Letters

Vermont Government

  • Governor Phil Scott
  • Lt. Governor David Zuckerman
  • State Reps By District
  • State Senators By District
  • VT Legislative Directory

Stay Informed!

  • Join our email list

More to See

(no title)

January 16, 2011 By Administrators

PHYSICAL MOVEMENTS OR OTHER EXTERNAL SIGNS OF DISTRESS ARE SOMETIMES EXHIBITED”

February 28, 2022 By Administrators

ACTION ALERT

January 11, 2022 By carolyn

Tags

abuse Act 39 Another Defeat for Assisted Suicide coercion Letters to the Editor: Pauline Austin Opponents of Assisted Suicide Greatly Outnumber Proponents at Manchester Forum. S.74 safeguards Story of a person with disabilities opposing assisted suicide telehealth

Article Categories

  • Ablism (2)
  • Acceptance of Unintended Consequences (5)
  • Action Alert (3)
  • Administrative (4)
  • Agism (4)
  • Alerts (24)
  • Animal euthanasia argument (4)
  • Board (1)
  • Brittany Maynard (1)
  • California (4)
  • Canada (3)
  • Canada Supreme Court (1)
  • Cheapness of Assisted Suicide (5)
  • Choice Becomes "Duty" to Die (14)
  • Chronic Diseases Rendered Terminal by Non-treatment (3)
  • Classism and Assisted Suicide (4)
  • Colorado (2)
  • Commentary (27)
  • Compassion and Choices (7)
  • Conflict of Interest (4)
  • Connecticut (6)
  • Conscience Rights (2)
  • Cost Cutting Agenda of Barbara Coombs Lee (2)
  • Countering the PAS lobby (1)
  • Court rulings (1)
  • CT (1)
  • Damage to Family (3)
  • Damage to Helpers (1)
  • Death with Dignity (3)
  • Defeats in other states (10)
  • Depression (8)
  • Devaluation of Lives with Disabilities (32)
  • Disability Rights Groups' Opposition (30)
  • Doctor's Power (3)
  • Dying with Real Dignity (1)
  • Editorials (5)
  • Elder Abuse (25)
  • Election 2014 (3)
  • Error Possibility (2)
  • Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide Contagion (2)
  • Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide Two Sides of the Same Coin (8)
  • Exemption options (4)
  • Expansion of Assisted Suicide/Euthanasia (16)
  • Georgia (3)
  • Germany (1)
  • Healthy people helped to commit suicide (2)
  • Language manipulation (3)
  • Legal Opinions (7)
  • Legislative Efforts in Other Countries (3)
  • Legislative Efforts in Other States (10)
  • Legislative Testimony (1)
  • Letters to the Editors of Newspapers (13)
  • Letters to the Legislature (2)
  • Maine (1)
  • Maryland (1)
  • Massachusetts (3)
  • Medical Opinions (18)
  • Medical Power (5)
  • Medical Societies (6)
  • Montana (2)
  • Moratorium (2)
  • Murder Invitation (3)
  • Nevada (1)
  • Never Investigated (1)
  • New Jersey (5)
  • New Mexico (1)
  • New York (4)
  • New York (1)
  • Not a Peaceful Death (5)
  • Oregon (4)
  • Other Countries (3)
  • Other States (11)
  • Out of State/General (10)
  • Palliative Care (7)
  • Personal Stories (6)
  • Pharmacists (6)
  • Polls (4)
  • Pro Assisted Suicide (1)
  • Prognosis Inaccuracy (3)
  • Racism and Assisted Suicide (1)
  • Randy Brock (1)
  • Rationing (3)
  • Reasons to Oppose (3)
  • Rejections of Assisted Suicide in Other Countries (3)
  • Rejections of Assisted Suicide in other states (5)
  • Relatives Won't Know (4)
  • Religious "movement" (1)
  • Repeal Effort (4)
  • Richard Doerflinger (1)
  • Selfishness of Proponents (3)
  • Selling of Suicide (7)
  • Silencing Opposition (2)
  • Slippery Slope (23)
  • Suicide Contagion (23)
  • Suicide Increase (10)
  • Suicide Tourism (3)
  • Talking Points (2)
  • Testimony before non-VT legislative bodies (3)
  • Transparency Lack (1)
  • True Dignity (22)
  • Uncategorized (375)
  • Unused Drug Dangers (1)
  • Unworkability if Regulations Attempt to Make AS "Safe" (1)
  • Updates (1)
  • US (1)
  • Vermont (18)
  • Vermont Alliance for Ethical Health Care (5)
  • Vermont Governor (4)
  • Vermont Legislature (61)
  • Videos (24)
  • Vote Count on Passage (4)
  • Vote Results (5)

Footer

Tags

abuse Act 39 Another Defeat for Assisted Suicide coercion Letters to the Editor: Pauline Austin Opponents of Assisted Suicide Greatly Outnumber Proponents at Manchester Forum. S.74 safeguards Story of a person with disabilities opposing assisted suicide telehealth

Recent

  • (no title)
  • PHYSICAL MOVEMENTS OR OTHER EXTERNAL SIGNS OF DISTRESS ARE SOMETIMES EXHIBITED”
  • ACTION ALERT
  • S.74: A step down the slippery slope
  • Vermont’s Second Assisted Suicide Report Does Not Reassure

Search

Copyright © 2025 · True Dignity · Log in